Pizza restaurants

Carbone's Pizzeria

4.0 430 reviews 04:00 PM - 10:00 PM 810 Lake St S, Forest Lake, MN 55025, United States

Discover this place

Carbone's Pizzeria, located at 810 Lake St S in Forest Lake, MN, has made a commendable comeback under new ownership, as many customers have noted. With a focus on delicious pizzas, the house special garners particular praise. Featuring a delightful blend of shrimp, pepperoni, and extra cheese, it's a favorite among regulars like Mark Johnson, who describes it as "always delicious." This cozy pizzeria offers more than just pizza. Their appetizers, like the flavorful Chicken Wings and cheesy Garlic Bread, set the stage for a satisfying meal. Crystal Rae raves about the wings and the creamy Italian dressing, which adds a unique twist that customers love. While most reviews celebrate the quality and taste, some feedback highlights issues with the service. Stephanie Tolrud shared a frustrating experience with delayed and improperly delivered orders. However, the general sentiment leans toward the positive, with patrons appreciating the commitment to quality after a period of decline. Aside from the mouth-watering pies, the Italian Burrito and Meatball Sandwich present exciting alternatives for those looking for variety. Overall, Carbone's Pizzeria is carving out a reputation for reliable, tasty food and a welcoming atmosphere, making it a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

No-contact delivery
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Carbone's Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Carbone's Pizzeria

4.0

430 reviews

100%

24%

13%

24%

Review highlights

Based on 430 reviews

Carbone's Pizzeria in Forest Lake is widely appreciated for its flavorful pizzas and diverse menu, including wings, cheesy breads, and salads with notably praised dressings. Customers frequently commend the quality and taste, especially since new ownership revitalized the food offerings. However, some patrons have expressed frustration with delivery times and order handling, reporting occasional issues with pizza condition upon arrival and customer service during replacements. Overall, Carbone's is recognized for its strong culinary appeal and menu variety, though consistency in delivery experience remains an area for improvement. The pizzeria maintains a loyal following who regularly enjoy its Italian and pizza specialties.

Mark Johnson

May 15, 2025

House special with both shrimp and pepperoni--extra cheese. My go-to pizza here, and it's always delicious.

Gail Judd

Apr 20, 2025

Great!! It had gone downhill a little bit, but it's back to be great food since new owners took over 1 yrs ago.

Ty Guy

Apr 08, 2025

pizza was RADICAL! and my pizza was NOT burnt to a crisp! wow! it tastied so good and i saw the hands of gabrial the archangel reach out to me and caress my shoulder.

Crystal Rae

Apr 05, 2025

Absolutely love this Carbones location the pizzas, wings, cheesy sticks, cheesy bread, salads and obsessed with there creamy Italian dressing the ranch is so good as well!

Stephanie Tolrud

Mar 10, 2025

We absolutely love the pizza at this place. But it's pretty frustrating when you order a pizza, have to wait over an hour for it to arrive & it shows up mutilated. Then when the replacement pizza is finally delivered the driver accuses you of intentionally destroying the first pizza stating, "it was fine when she dropped it off."

Hayly Feist

Mar 09, 2025

Food was delicious!! Yummy garlic cheese bread, dinner salad add for only 99 cents and creamy Italian dressing was good, and spaghetti was great!! Very nicely priced! Service was great and friendly! 3 pool tables were cool and fun, nice to have something different.

Ken Kralick

Mar 07, 2025

Carbonne’s of Forest Lake has been in the town for ages and it’s always as expected. I’ve been eating pizza at this place since the late 1970s and I’ve visited hundreds of times. The interior and pizza recipe has not changed over the ages. They serve reliable Thin crust pizza with plenty of cheese and ample toppings. Their service has never failed to be friendly to me. The truest sense of their ability? Pizza Hut is less than a quarter mile away and has been there since the 1980s. Yet Carbonne’s remains. That’s some staying power - for good reason.

Terri Seidl

Feb 22, 2025

Good service, great pizza! This was our first visit. We came on a Saturday night at about 8:15. Seated promptly and food came quickly. We ordered the pizza fries appetizer (basically garlic butter and cheese on a crust) and a large special. The appetizer was fantastic!! The crust was buttery and garlicky and crispy. Soooooo good! The pizza was great as well. Plenty of toppings and loaded to the edge. Server was great, checked on us often, and she kept our drinks full. Will definitely be back!